Jorge, We Hardly Knew YaThough reliever Jorge Julio has actually been pitching well of late, there's no question that the Mets trade of Julio to Arizona for Orlando Hernandez was a good one. Even at this stage of his career, El Duque should, if he can stay healthy, be at least an adequate number 5 starter for the Mets. Julio, in contrast, can be replaced by Heath Bell.
Having said that, I disagree with Mets GM Omar Minaya that Hernandez is an upgrade over Kris Benson, who the Mets traded in January to acquire Julio. Benson is inconsistent, but he pitches a lot of innings, and in both 2005 and thus far 2006, his ERA has been 100 points or more below El Duque's.
posted on 5/25/2006